Probing the world of alien abduction stories

When people remember traumatic events, they’ll show signs of their distress, like increased heart rate, sweating and muscle tension. These reactions are often seen as a testament to the authenticity of the memory – some have gone so far as to use physical reactions to memories to prove their validity, even when the memory is as far-fetched as ritual abuse by satanic cults. Recently, though, a team from Harvard has challenged the significance of these reactions by looking into one of the most widely reported and least likely memories people claim: alien abductions.

From American Psychological Society :

Probing the world of alien abduction stories


Even the unlikeliest of memories can get a big reaction

When people remember traumatic events, they’ll show signs of their distress, like increased heart rate, sweating and muscle tension. These reactions are often seen as a testament to the authenticity of the memory – some have gone so far as to use physical reactions to memories to prove their validity, even when the memory is as far-fetched as ritual abuse by satanic cults. Recently, though, a team from Harvard has challenged the significance of these reactions by looking into one of the most widely reported and least likely memories people claim: alien abductions.

The study, conducted by Richard McNally, Natasha Lasko, Susan Clancy, Michael Macklin, Roger Pitman and Scott Orr at Harvard University, will be published in the July issue of Psychological Science, a journal of the American Psychological Society.

The researchers recruited people who reported being abducted and had them describe the alien encounters as well as other stressful, happy, and neutral memories. The researchers converted these stories into 30-second audiotaped narratives and played them for the ”abductees” while recording heart rate, sweat production, and facial muscle tension, three strong indicators of stress. The researchers also played the tapes for a control group of people who had no memories of alien encounters.

The researchers found that those who claimed to have been abducted had similarly strong reactions to the stressful narrative and the alien abduction, and weaker reactions to the happy and neutral narratives. The control group barely reacted to any of the stories.

When people believe they’ve been abducted by aliens, recalling their abduction can evoke reactions not unlike those evoked by a genuine memory that is stressful. This suggests that a person’s reaction to a memory doesn’t indicate whether the event happened, but only whether the memory, real or not, is traumatic.

1 thought on “Probing the world of alien abduction stories”

  1. This suggests that a person’s reaction to a memory doesn’t indicate whether the event happened, but only whether the memory, real or not, is traumatic.

    “suggests” … nice, careful wording.

    Because, of course, that conclusion is making the assumption that said abductees’ memories are not real.

    Now I’m no more inclined to believe that alien abductions are real than any of the rest of y’all, but I do believe in good, sound, peer-reviewed science. And I’d challenge any of you to find me a strong, peer-reviewed paper that clearly demonstrates that these memories are false. It would be a good thing, actually, because then this APS paper would be much stronger.

    Come to think of it, maybe it does exist; there was a lot of research into UFO reports in the 50’s through 70’s, after all, maybe someone went through and thoroughly researched a bunch of abduction claims. Does anyone with access to this APS paper know whether it cites such research?

    Reply

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.