Wives with a romantic view of marriage are less likely to do volunteer work, leading their husbands to volunteer less as well. But husbands’ romantic view of marriage was associated with neither their own nor their wives’ volunteering, according to a Baylor University study.
In the study, “Marital Investments and Community Involvement: A Test of Coser’s Greedy Marriage Thesis” published in the journal Sociological Perspectives, Young-Il Kim, Ph.D., research assistant professor in Baylor’s Institute for Studies of Religion, and co-researcher Jeffrey Dew, Ph.D., professor in the School of Family Life at Brigham Young University, set out to test the claim of a classic study — “Greedy Institutions” — done more than 40 years ago. Sociologist Lewis A. Coser argued that marriage is a greedy institution demanding exclusive commitment from married couples. This makes it harder for married couples to spread out their time and energy to other people and institutions, Coser said.
“Wives who take a more romantic view of marriage appear to seek (emotional) satisfaction primarily through husbands, which might take couples’ time and energy away from their involvement in the community,” Kim and Dew wrote.
Previous studies exploring the “greedy marriage” concept typically focused on whether married people are less likely than unmarried people to maintain personal connections. One particular study found that the married are less likely than the never married and the divorced to stay in touch with their parents, giving or receiving less emotional, financial and practical help.
“Surprisingly, a large body of previous work has defined greediness as someone who spends little time with his or her personal network, paying no attention to other aspects of greediness: making little time for the wider community,” Kim said. “I was even more surprised that no study has tackled the greedy marriage thesis by investigating the married couple as the unit of analysis. Coser’s argument is not based on the comparison between married and unmarried individuals. According to Coser, greedy characteristics in marriage stem from the couples themselves. It is the husband and the wife that characterize the nature of their marriage.”
For their study, Kim and Dew chose to investigate the dynamics inside marriages to see whether each spouse’s volunteering is predicted by each other’s marital beliefs and couple’s time spent together alone.
They analyzed data from the Survey of Marital Generosity, a recent United States national sample of 1,368 married couples ages 18 to 45. Participants were asked about their views of marriage, how often they volunteered, how much time they spent solely with each other and how often they attended religious services.
While allowing for such variables as work schedules, education and whether the couples had children, the researchers focused on:
- Whether couples took a “soul mate” view of marriage, making it the top priority in life; or whether they held a more traditional view, placing additional values on other functions of marriage such as raising children and fulfilling financial needs.
- How much time they spent solely with each other.
What Kim and Dew found was that:
- Wives’ view of the marriage as “soul mates” was associated with less volunteering of both wife and husband, but a man’s having a soul mate view of marriage was not associated with volunteering by either spouse.
- Time spent alone with one’s spouse was positively associated with husbands’ reports of their own volunteering.
The fact that spousal time had a positive association with husbands’ volunteering was unexpected by Kim and Dew, who had hypothesized that time spent together would inhibit volunteering.
“I thought it was interesting to see the gender difference here,” Kim said. “One possible explanation is that couples who invest more time in their marriage are more likely to have better relationships, and husbands in such marriages may be more likely to volunteer with their wives, who may push them to volunteer more.”
Responses to survey questions showed that:
- 53 percent of wives and 55 percent of husbands indicated that they viewed marriage as a relationship between soul mates; the rest placed additional values on other functions of marriage, such as raising children and fulfilling financial needs.
- The average time participants volunteered was one to two hours monthly.
- Couples averaged spending quality time solely with each other about once a week.
- The average religious attendance was once or twice a month, with wives attending slightly more than husbands.