Archived Science Blog page from 2010. It stays on Science Blog so the original link still works. It is not a current article. Back to Science Blog
Setting the record straight on weight loss
It's time to set the record straight. The only reliable way to lose weight is to eat less or exercise more. Preferably both.
So why bother to state the obvious? Because a body of scientific literature has arisen over recent years, suggesting that fat oxidation -- burning the fats we eat as opposed to the carbohydrates -- is enough to promote fat loss. It isn't.
Sydney scientists have demonstrated that mice genetically altered to burn fats in preference to carbohydrates, will convert the unburned carbohydrates into stored fat anyway, and their ultimate weight and body composition will be the same as normal mice.
It all comes down to an enzyme known as ACC2 (acetyl-CoA carboxylase), which controls whether cells burn fats or carbohydrates. When it was shown that 'blocking' ACC2 will force cells to burn fats in preference to carbohydrates, many assumed that such 'fat burning' could make fat stores evaporate, and make people thin without changing food intake or energy expenditure.
Associate Professor Greg Cooney, from Sydney's Garvan Institute of Medical Research, discusses misconceptions surrounding ACC2 in findings that appear in the prestigious international journal,
"Our data urges a correction in people's concept of a magic bullet - something that will miraculously make them thin while they sit on the couch watching television," said Professor Cooney.
"While none of the large pharmaceutical companies have marketed ACC2 inhibitors, there are many kinds of so-called 'fat-burning pills' available in the health food, body building and alternative medicine markets, where limited clinical effectiveness data are required."
"Many such products can also contain potentially harmful stimulants or come with a recommendation to follow a calorie-controlled diet and do more exercise while taking them. If you follow those recommendations, then of course you'll lose weight - but you'd lose it anyway."
"The energy you use in your home can come from a coal-fired power station, hydroelectric power, or a wind turbine. You won't know which because the end result is electricity."
"The energy that fuels your body can come from fats, proteins or carbohydrates. You won't know which because the end result is ATP, or cellular energy."
"Your body will use the energy it needs and store the leftover fats, proteins or carbohydrates as fat. When you do the sums, it's ultimately a matter of calories in and calories out."
"It's important to stress that the focus of our study was limited to an analysis of the impact of fat oxidation on overall fatness. We didn't investigate all impacts of fat oxidation -- and so we don't rule out benefits of burning off fats in specific tissues."
"For example, manipulating fat metabolism may - or may not - lead to better insulin action in muscles or in the liver. Should insulin action be improved, that would obviously benefit obese people with Type 2 diabetes. But we can't comment either way until we do the experiments."
And the take-home message? Follow a healthy, balanced diet and get plenty of exercise.
The Garvan Institute of Medical Research was founded in 1963. Initially a research department of St Vincent's Hospital in Sydney, it is now one of Australia's largest medical research institutions with nearly 500 scientists, students and support staff. Garvan's main research programs are: Cancer, Diabetes & Obesity, Immunology and Inflammation, Osteoporosis and Bone Biology, and Neuroscience. The Garvan's mission is to make significant contributions to medical science that will change the directions of science and medicine and have major impacts on human health. The outcome of Garvan's discoveries is the development of better methods of diagnosis, treatment, and ultimately, prevention of disease.
Fat cells are like batteries that expand to hold the energy taken in. I agree with the article's overall statement on that aspect, but I think the magic bullet they're looking for, is not wanted in the first place. That magic bullet is to make food tasteless, or less desirable in those that eat too much. For that, you have to aim at the pleasure center of the brain, the pleasure the obese get out of eating food. There are different directions here, outright banning of advertising of food, laws to make food taste worse overall, or some drug for the obese to lower the pleasure they get out of eating. Stomach stapling also does this, making the obese sick if they eat too much, lowering their pleasure based on the amount they eat.
Alcoholics have a pill available to make them sick if they drink too much, the obese probably need a pill for eating too much. Getting them to take it, might be similar to that of alcoholics, where they're forced to take it upon getting too obese. Is there a pill to cause the obese to dislike food? This might be a better direction to head.
There is also the other aspect, stomachs tend to shrink when people back off from eating so much, indirectly lowering intake over time. If most people would simply lower their portions, and look for lower calorie foods, over time they would naturally tend to lower their weight while not being hungry all the time. IMO.
Bias towards unsupported (and unrelated) weight loss techniques
None of the science described in this summary seems to support the conclusion in the lead. Perhaps it has been demonstrated that when fat is burned instead of carbohydrates, no significant change in fat deposition is observed, but what does that have to do with the statement "The only reliable way to lose weight is to eat less or exercise more"?
The conclusion in the lead is just as misleading as the position this research seems aimed at debunking. This might be forgivable, except there's little other research that supports the conclusion put forward here.
To my knowledge, there are no compelling studies which support calorie restricted diets combined with exercise regimens as an effective sustained weight loss technique. Quite the contrary, there are many studies which show this approach to be completely ineffective.
I'm sure there is good science here, but I see no indication that it is of sufficient scope to support a recommendation to "eat less or exercise more. Preferably both."
Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
Allowed HTML tags: <a> <p> <sub> <blockquote> <br> <hspace> <img> <em> <strong> <cite> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <width> <height> <dd>
Diabetes treatment may lie in helping muscles to burn fat better
Findings that should speed the development of drugs for Parkinson's disease
Low-carb diet burns more excess liver fat than low-calorie diet
‘Knocking Out’ Cell Receptor May Help Block Fat Deposits in Tissues, Prevent Weight Gain
Science Blog was started in August 2002. It lives, breathes and eats press releases from research organizations around the globe. Most of what you read here are press releases from the outfits named in the stories themselves. Got a news story you think belongs here?