GAO: Defense Dept.’s Gulf War Illness Research Faulty

The U.S. General Accounting Office has determined that because of faulty assumptions, conclusions by the U.S. Department of Defense on Gulf War Illness cannot be supported. “DOD’s and MOD’s conclusions about troops’ exposure to CW agents, based on DOD and CIA plume modeling, cannot be adequately supported. The models were not fully developed for analyzing long-range dispersion of CW agents as an environmental hazard. The modeling assumptions as to source term data–quantity and purity of the agent–were inaccurate because they were uncertain, incomplete, and nonvalidated.”From the U.S. General Accounting Office:GAO: Defense Dept.’s Gulf War Research Faulty

DOD’s and MOD’s conclusions about troops’ exposure to CW agents, based on DOD and CIA plume modeling, cannot be adequately supported. The models were not fully developed for analyzing long-range dispersion of CW agents as an environmental hazard. The modeling assumptions as to source term data–quantity and purity of the agent–were inaccurate because they were uncertain, incomplete, and nonvalidated.

The plume heights used in the modeling were underestimated, and so were the hazard areas. Postwar field testing used to estimate the source term did not realistically simulate the actual conditions of bombings or demolitions.

Finally, the results of all models–DOD and non-DOD models–showed wide divergences as to plume size and path. DOD’s and VA’s conclusions about no association between exposure to CW agents and rates of hospitalization and mortality, based on two epidemiological studies conducted and funded by DOD and VA, also cannot be adequately supported because of study weaknesses. In both studies, flawed criteria–DOD’s plume model and DOD’s estimation of potentially exposed troops based on this model–were used to determine exposure. This may have resulted in large-scale misclassification.

Troops under the path of the plume were classified as exposed; those not under the path, as not exposed. But troops classified as not exposed under one DOD model could be classified as exposed under another DOD model. Under non-DOD models, however, a larger number of troops could be classified as exposed. Finally, as an outcome measure, hospitalization rate failed to capture the types of chronic illnesses that Gulf War veterans report but that typically do not lead to hospitalization.

Leave a Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Science Every Day

Cutting-edge science delivered direct to your inbox.