Crocodile tears please thirsty butterflies and bees

The butterfly (Dryas iulia) and the bee (Centris sp.) were most likely seeking scarce minerals and an extra boost of protein. On a beautiful December day in 2013, they found the precious nutrients in the tears of a spectacled caiman (Caiman crocodilus), relaxing on the banks of the Río Puerto Viejo in northeastern Costa Rica.

A boat carrying students, photographers, and aquatic ecologist Carlos de la Rosa was passing slowing and quietly by, and caught the moment on film. They watched [and photographed] in barely suppressed excitement for a quarter of an hour while the caiman basked placidly and the insects fluttered about the corners of its eyes.

De la Rosa reported the encounter in a peer-reviewed letter in the May 2014 issue of the Ecological Society of America’s journal Frontiers in Ecology and the Environment.

“It was one of those natural history moments that you long to see up close,” said de la Rosa, the director of the La Selva Biological Station for the Organization for Tropical Field Studies in San Pedro, Costa Rica. “But then the question becomes, what’s going on in here? Why are these insects tapping into this resource?”

Though bountiful in the ocean, salt is often a rare and valuable resource on land, especially for vegetarians. It is not uncommon to see butterflies sipping mineral-laden water from mud puddles. When minerals are rare in the soil, animals sometimes gather salt and other rare minerals and proteins from sweat, tears, urine, and even blood.

De la Rosa had seen butterflies and moths in the Amazon feeding on the tears of turtles and a few caimans. Tear-drinking “lachryphagous” behavior in bees had only recently been observed by biologists. He remembered a 2012 report of a solitary bee sipping the tears of a yellow-spotted river turtle in Ecuador’s Yasuní National Park. But how common is this behavior?

Back at the field station, he did a little research. He was surprised to find more evidence of tear-drinking than he expected in the collective online record of wilderness enthusiasts, casual tourists, professional photographers, and scientists. He now thinks the phenomenon may not be as rare as biologists had assumed—just hard to witness.

“I did a Google search for images and I found out that it is quite common! A lot of people have recorded butterflies, and some bees, doing this,” said de la Rosa.

A search of the scientific literature produced a detailed study of bees drinking human tears in Thailand, as well as the remembered October 2012 “Trails and Tribulations” story about the Ecuadorian bee and the river turtle byOlivier Dangles and Jérôme Casas in ESA’s Frontiers. This experience reminds us that the world still has many surprises for ecologists, de la Rosa said. There so much still to be studied. De la Rosa is a specialist in the biology of non-biting midges, and a natural historian, with his eyes always open to new discoveries. Scientists at La Selva have discovered hundreds of species of aquatic insects that are still unnamed and undescribed.

“I have over 450 undescribed species from Costa Rica in my laboratory. If I did nothing for the rest of my life but collaborate with taxonomists and try to describe those, I would never get done,” he said.

De la Rosa’s job as director of La Selva Biological Station brings him an unusual number of serendipitous encounters with wildlife. He lives on site in the lowland rainforest, and he never needs an alarm clock. Howler monkeys wake him every morning.

“I learned I have to carry a camera with me 24/7, because you never know what you’re going to find when you’re walking to the office or the dining hall,” he said. One day, he spied a new species of dragonfly on his way to breakfast. It had emerged from its larval form in the small pool of water caught in the cupped leaves of a bromeliad plant. He did a double-take. Dragonflies don’t live on bromeliads. Or do they?

“Those are the kinds of things that, you know, you don’t plan for them, you can’t plan for them,” de la Rosa said. There was only one known species of dragonfly in the world that lives in bromeliads. Now there will be two. “You just keep your eyes open and have curiosity, and when you see something that doesn’t seem to fit, dig.”

Substack subscription form sign up
The material in this press release comes from the originating research organization. Content may be edited for style and length. Want more? Sign up for our daily email.

24 thoughts on “Crocodile tears please thirsty butterflies and bees”

  1. Everyone has heard the phrase “crying crocodile tears” which is used to describe a false display of emotion. Crocodile tears are real and like our own tears it comes from the lachrymal glands. The fluid helps the crocodile to clean the eye and probably also helps to reduce bacterial growth and prevents the eye from drying out.
    It is amazing to read about these insects that have the guts to go and drink the caiman’s tears to satisfy their mineral need, I would not dare to attempt something like that. It is scary to think about how much we miss out on small things like this. There is so many things we still need to learn, but we need to see to truly understand. Nature is beautiful, bizarre and brutal.

  2. This article is enlightening. It is something out of the ordinary. People don’t usually talk about crocodile tears in a literal sense. It’s interesting to see how organisms help each other. There is so much in the world that has not yet been discovered and it would be amazing to witness a few of these discoveries..

  3. Quite enlightening, often one does not realize just how much there is that scientists still have to discover or how seemingly rare phenomena might in fact be quite common. Perhaps such phenomena seem rare as they are not often witnessed (“hard to witness” as stated in the article), or are such phenomena becoming more common due to changing conditions perhaps still it is simply a case of a lack of understanding and if one learned more about the phenomena they would be far easier to witness (as one would know why they occur and so when and where to look for them).

    It is exciting as a science student to be reminded that there are still plenty of discoveries to make and new understandings to form. It would certainty seem advantageous to keep an inquisitive mind, one need never stop learning.

  4. This is an incredible article. It makes you realize how much you’re missing when you’re looking but not really seeing. And to think that there are so many species which have not been named. Who knows what’s still out there.

    As I read this article, I wondered how these butterflies and bees know when they need these minerals. Do they, for example, get dizzy when deficient in a certain mineral, like humans often do when they do not have enough iron in their blood. Do they maybe get “cravings” after it?

    These suggestions might sound a little bizarre and “creative”, But as Einstein said: “Imagination is more important than knowledge. For knowledge is limited to all we now know and understand, while imagination embraces the entire world, and all there ever will be to know and understand.”

Comments are closed.