In the United States, a wide, toothy smile is close to a social requirement. It shows up in school photos, job interviews, customer service and campaign posters, and most Americans read it as a sign of warmth, confidence and good character. Research from dozens of countries suggests that reading is far from universal. The same smile that looks friendly and appealing in Ohio can look naive, insincere or even superior somewhere else.

It is not true that only Americans find a big smile attractive. People in many cultures respond well to smiling faces. But a growing body of cross-cultural research shows that Americans value broad, excited smiles more than many other societies do, and that people elsewhere can draw very different conclusions from the same expression.

A smile is not always a compliment

Much of what psychologists know about smiling comes from studies run in Western, educated, industrialized, rich and democratic societies, often shortened to WEIRD. In that research, smiling people are usually judged as happier, more attractive, more competent and friendlier than people who do not smile.

A team led by Kuba Krys of the Polish Academy of Sciences set out to test whether those judgments hold everywhere. Their study, published in the Journal of Nonverbal Behavior in 2016, asked people in 44 cultures to rate photos of the same individuals smiling and not smiling.

The results did not line up neatly with the American view. In some cultures, the smiling version of a person was rated as less intelligent than the non-smiling version of the same person. That pattern appeared in societies that score low on what researchers call uncertainty avoidance, a measure from the GLOBE project of how much a culture relies on rules, norms and predictability to manage an uncertain future.

The researchers also found a link with corruption. In countries with high levels of corruption, people trusted smiling individuals less than non-smiling ones. In a setting where people may have good reason to be wary, a ready smile can look like a sales tactic rather than an honest signal.

The authors warned that a smile can carry a social cost depending on where it is used. For travelers, managers and anyone working across borders, the message was simple: an expression that builds trust at home may not do the same job abroad.

Americans prize excitement

Why do Americans lean so heavily on big smiles? Psychologist Jeanne Tsai of Stanford University has spent years studying what she calls ideal affect, meaning the feelings people want to have, as opposed to the feelings they actually have.

Her work shows that Americans tend to value high-energy positive states such as excitement and enthusiasm. People in many East Asian cultures, including Hong Kong Chinese participants in her studies, place more value on calm, low-energy positive states such as peacefulness and contentment. An excited smile, with the mouth wide open and teeth showing, expresses the first kind of feeling. A closed, gentle smile fits the second.

In a 2016 study in the journal Emotion, Tsai and her colleagues analyzed official photos of political and business leaders. Top-ranked American leaders, 98 in all, showed more excited smiles in their official photos than 91 top-ranked Chinese leaders. A second study comparing candidates and executives in the United States and Taiwan found a similar pattern.

In a third study, the team looked at legislators across 10 nations. The more a nation valued excitement, the more excited its leaders’ smiles were in official photos. That link held even after the researchers accounted for differences in national wealth, level of democracy and human development, which suggests the pattern reflects cultural values rather than economic conditions alone.

Tsai’s group has found the same contrast in material aimed at children. In earlier research, best-selling American children’s storybooks showed characters with more excited expressions and wider smiles than best-selling Taiwanese storybooks. The preference for a big, bright smile appears to be taught early.

A nation of many origins smiles more openly

Another line of research points to history. A team led by Magdalena Rychlowska, then at the University of Wisconsin-Madison, asked whether the mix of people who settled a country could shape how its people express emotion. Their study appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences in 2015.

The researchers used a measure of historical heterogeneity, which counts how many source countries a nation’s present-day population descends from since the year 1500. The United States, built by waves of migration from around the world, ranks high on that measure. Many other countries draw most of their population from a single source.

Using data on emotional display rules from 32 countries and 5,340 participants, the team found that more heterogeneous countries had norms favoring more open emotional expression. The idea is that when neighbors do not share a language, customs or history, people need clear, readable signals to show friendly intentions. A broad smile does that job well.

A second survey of 726 people in nine countries, including the United States, looked at what people believed a smile means. In more heterogeneous cultures, people tended to see smiles as a way of showing friendliness and building bonds. In more homogeneous cultures, people were more likely to read a smile as a sign of dominance or a display of superiority.

Seen that way, the American smile is less a personality trait than a social tool, shaped over centuries by the need for strangers from different backgrounds to get along.

What this means in everyday life

None of this means people outside the United States dislike smiles or find them unattractive. Smiling is recognized around the world, and a genuine smile between friends rarely causes confusion. The differences show up most with strangers, in professional settings and in official images, where people rely on expressions to judge trust, competence and intent.

For an American working abroad, a constant broad smile may be read as eagerness, a lack of seriousness or a sign that something is being sold. For a visitor to the United States, a calm or neutral face may be read as cold or unhappy, even when the person feels perfectly content.

The research also has limits. Studies of smiling usually rely on photos and ratings rather than real conversations, and national averages hide large differences between individuals and regions. Countries also change over time, and younger people exposed to global media may read smiles differently from their parents.

Still, the findings from three separate research programs point in the same direction. What counts as an appealing, trustworthy face depends partly on where a person grew up and what their culture teaches them to want to feel. The big, bright American smile is one answer to that question, not the only one.

Photo by Andrea Piacquadio on Pexels