When people want to make something better, whether a project, an organization or their own lives, they usually look for something to add: a new habit, a new rule, a new tool, a new commitment. Far less often do they ask what they could take away.
That tendency is not just a matter of personal style. A series of experiments published in Nature in 2021 found that people systematically overlook subtraction as a way to improve things, even when removing something would be simpler, cheaper or more effective. The findings suggest that one of the most useful questions for anyone trying to succeed may be one that rarely comes to mind: what should I stop doing?
A request for ideas, and what was missing
The research team, Gabrielle Adams, Benjamin Converse, Andrew Hales and Leidy Klotz of the University of Virginia, began partly by examining real-world records. In one analysis, they looked at the suggestions an incoming university president received after asking for ideas on how the university could better serve its students and community. Only 11 percent of the responses proposed removing an existing regulation, practice or program. The rest suggested adding something.
The idea for the project came from Klotz, an engineer who had noticed that designs created by taking elements away were surprisingly uncommon. Working with Adams, a social psychologist, the team set out to test whether people actually overlook subtraction when they are asked to change things.
Bricks, grids and golf courses
Across eight studies with more than 1,100 participants, the researchers gave people a range of problems to solve, including a geometric puzzle, a miniature golf course design and a Lego structure.
In the Lego task, a small figure sat under a roof supported by a single block at one corner. Participants were offered $1 to change the structure so it could hold a real masonry brick on top without collapsing onto the figure. They could add new Lego pieces at a cost of 10 cents each. The simplest solution, however, was to remove the lone supporting block so the roof rested directly on the base, which cost nothing.
When participants were told only that each added piece cost 10 cents, 41 percent chose to subtract. When the instructions also mentioned that removing pieces was free, that figure rose to 61 percent. The subtractive option was always available; many people simply did not think of it until reminded.
A similar pattern appeared in a grid task, in which people were asked to make a pattern of colored boxes symmetrical. Many added boxes to the emptier side rather than removing them from the fuller side, even when removing would have been more efficient.
Why subtraction gets overlooked
The researchers found that people were not rejecting subtractive solutions because they thought those solutions were worse. They were failing to consider them in the first place. Converse described additive ideas as having a privileged status: they tend to come to mind quickly and easily, while subtractive ideas take more effort to find.
That explanation was supported by further experiments. When people were cued to think about subtraction, given more opportunity to think or had a chance to practice, they were more likely to arrive at subtractive solutions. When they were distracted or hurried, they were less likely to.
In a commentary in Nature, consumer psychologist Tom Meyvis of New York University and a colleague suggested another possible factor. Subtractive solutions may be less appreciated. People might expect to receive less credit for removing something than for adding something new, which could further encourage them to reach for additions.
What this means for success
The study did not test career or life success directly. But its findings fit with other research on why people end up stretched too thin.
One well-known example concerns time. In 2005, Gal Zauberman of the University of North Carolina and John Lynch of Duke University reported in the Journal of Experimental Psychology: General that people consistently expect to have more spare time in the future than they have now, and that this optimism is stronger for time than for money. As a result, people tend to agree to commitments down the road that they would never accept for today, then find themselves just as busy when the time arrives. The researchers noted that people are consistently surprised to be so busy today.
Another line of research concerns focus. A 2009 Stanford study published in PNAS by Eyal Ophir, Clifford Nass and Anthony Wagner found that people who habitually juggled many streams of media at once were more easily distracted by irrelevant information and performed worse on a task-switching test than those who multitasked less. Later studies have produced mixed results, so the finding is best seen as suggestive rather than settled. Still, it points in the same direction: doing more at once does not necessarily mean getting more done.
Taken together, this research suggests that many people’s default response to wanting more success, adding goals, tasks, commitments and tools, may sometimes work against them.
Making subtraction easier to see
The good news from the Nature study is that the bias toward adding is not fixed. A simple reminder that removal is an option was enough to shift many people’s choices. The researchers have expressed hope that simply getting people to think about subtraction more might help reveal improvements that are usually missed.
In practice, that might mean building a deliberate pause into decisions. Before adding a new project, a new rule or a new habit, it can help to ask what could be removed instead. Reviewing commitments, meetings or regular tasks with the question “What would happen if we stopped this?” can surface options that otherwise stay hidden. Because the study found people miss subtractive options more often when rushed, taking a little extra time before deciding may also help.
Limits
The research has its limits. Most of the experiments involved puzzles and design problems, not decisions about careers or businesses, and the study did not show that subtraction is always better. Adding is sometimes exactly the right move. Open questions also remain, including whether the bias applies across cultures and how it develops in childhood.
But the core finding has held up across a range of tasks: when people set out to improve something, they tend to overlook the possibility of taking something away. For anyone looking to do better, that may be worth remembering.
Representative image. Photo: https://kaboompics.com/ / Pexels.
Spot an error in this article? Email [email protected]


