For a long time, retirement was treated as the reward at the end of a working life: stop at 65, put your feet up, and enjoy the years ahead. More recently, a different idea has gained ground. Perhaps the healthiest option is to keep working for as long as you can, or not to retire at all.
Several large studies lend some support to that view, linking later retirement with lower rates of dementia and death. But other research finds that stopping work can improve health, too. Taken together, the evidence suggests the answer depends a great deal on the person and the job.
Later retirement and dementia
The largest study of retirement age and dementia comes from France. Researchers led by Carole Dufouil of INSERM, the French national health research institute, analyzed records for more than 429,000 self-employed workers, most of them shopkeepers and craftspeople such as bakers and woodworkers. The study was published in the European Journal of Epidemiology in 2014.
At the time of the analysis, participants were 74 years old on average and had been retired for about 12 years. Just under 3 percent had been diagnosed with dementia. The risk was lower for each additional year people had worked before retiring. Dufouil reported that each extra year of work was associated with a 3.2 percent lower risk of dementia. Someone who retired at 65 had about a 15 percent lower risk than someone who retired at 60, after accounting for other factors.
An obvious concern is reverse causation. People in the early stages of dementia might retire sooner because they are already struggling, which would make early retirement look harmful when it is really a symptom. The researchers tested this by excluding people diagnosed with dementia within five and ten years of retiring. The pattern stayed the same. Still, the authors wrote that further evidence is needed to judge whether the link is causal.
The usual explanation is “use it or lose it”. Work tends to keep people mentally challenged, socially connected and physically active, all of which are thought to support brain health. That idea fits with earlier findings from the Whitehall II study of British civil servants, which found verbal memory declined faster after retirement than before, a result ScienceBlog has covered previously.
Later retirement and survival
A second line of research looks at mortality. In 2016, researchers at Oregon State University published an analysis in the Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health using data from the Health and Retirement Study, a long-running survey of older Americans. They focused on 2,956 people who began the study in 1992 and had retired by 2010.
Because poor health is a common reason for retiring early, and is also linked to dying sooner, the team split participants into two groups. Those who said health was a factor in their decision to retire were classed as unhealthy retirees, and the rest as healthy retirees. About two-thirds fell into the healthy group.
Among healthy retirees, working one year longer was associated with an 11 percent lower risk of death from any cause over the study period, after accounting for demographic, lifestyle and health factors. Among unhealthy retirees, an extra year of work was linked to a 9 percent lower risk. The authors noted that the pattern held even though the healthier group was generally better off in education, wealth and health behaviors.
Lead author Chenkai Wu suggested that work brings economic and social benefits that may influence how long people live. The researchers also cautioned that they could not see everything happening in participants’ lives after retirement, and that much remained to be understood.
When retiring helps
Not all of the evidence points the same way. A 2015 study in the Journal of Health Economics by Peter Eibich took a different approach. Rather than comparing people who chose to retire at different ages, he used financial incentives built into Germany’s pension system. Those rules nudge people to retire at particular ages, which makes it possible to compare otherwise similar workers who retired at slightly different times. This kind of design is generally better at separating cause from coincidence.
Eibich found that retirement improved people’s own ratings of their health and their mental health, and reduced their use of outpatient medical care. When he looked at why, three factors stood out: relief from work-related stress and strain, more sleep, and more frequent physical exercise.
That finding is a useful counterweight. For someone in a demanding, stressful or physically hard job, retiring may free up time and energy for the very things that protect health.
Why the studies disagree
The two sets of findings are not necessarily in conflict. They may be measuring different things in different people.
The French and American studies looked at long-term outcomes such as dementia and death, and they compared people who retired at different ages in the normal course of their lives. Even with careful adjustments, those comparisons can be affected by differences that researchers cannot fully measure, such as personality, motivation or undiagnosed illness. The French sample was also made up of self-employed workers, who may have more control over their work than many employees.
The German study focused on shorter-term health, mental wellbeing and daily habits, using a design that is better at isolating the effect of retirement itself. Its results suggest that what people do after they stop working matters a great deal.
A common thread runs through all of this research. The benefits linked to work, such as mental challenge, social contact and physical activity, are not unique to paid jobs. The Alzheimer’s Association, commenting on the French findings, stressed that the results did not mean everyone needs to delay retirement. What matters, it said, is staying cognitively and socially engaged in whatever people enjoy.
What it means
The evidence does not support a single rule for everyone. For people who enjoy their work, find it stimulating and are in good health, carrying on, perhaps part-time, may bring real benefits. For those in stressful or physically draining jobs, retiring may improve health, especially if the extra time goes into sleep, exercise and other activities they value.
Either way, the research points to the same practical lesson. Whether or not you keep working, the healthiest later years seem to be those that stay mentally, socially and physically active.
Representative image. Photo: Andrea Piacquadio / Pexels.


