The Health Claim That Drives Dog Food Prices Up 18%

Pet owners willingly pay premium prices for dog food marketed with specific health benefits, with allergy-relief products commanding the highest price premiums at nearly 18% above standard formulations, according to new research analyzing over 1,200 dry dog food products.

The study reveals how the humanization of pets—treating them as family members rather than just animals—is driving significant price variations in the rapidly expanding pet food market, which grew from $65.9 billion in 2012 to $123.6 billion in 2022.

The comprehensive analysis, published in the Journal of Agricultural and Applied Economics, examined pricing patterns across 60+ brands to understand which health claims justify higher costs and which might offer better value for budget-conscious pet parents.

The Premium Health Claims

Researchers from the University of Arkansas and Kansas State University discovered that certain health attributes consistently command higher prices, while others actually correlate with discounts. The pattern reflects both consumer demand and manufacturing complexities associated with specialized formulations.

“Trends like premiumization and humanization have made pet owners more aware of the health and safety of their pets’ food in an attempt to keep their pets healthy and happy,” the study noted. “Premiumization refers to customers demanding more premium and super-premium products, while humanization involves owners perceiving and treating pets as human family members.”

Andrew Anderson, co-author and assistant professor at the University of Arkansas, explained the cultural shift: “Pets have gone from being in the doghouse to being a member of the family, so when it comes to the diet of the pet, that’s a big way in which that bond manifests.”

The Price Hierarchy of Pet Health

The research revealed distinct pricing tiers based on health claims, with some surprising findings about which conditions pet owners prioritize financially:

• Highest premiums: Allergy relief (17.82% premium), sensitive digestion (3.77% premium)
• Significant discounts: Dental care (-7.41%), immune support (-2.66%)
• Most expensive by average price: Allergy relief ($3.89/lb), weight management ($3.52/lb)
• Most affordable: Dental breath care ($2.63/lb), muscle care ($2.72/lb)

The stark contrast between allergy-relief products and dental care formulations highlights how specialized health concerns command premium pricing, while more general wellness features compete primarily on value.

Understanding Market Dynamics

The study analyzed data from Chewy.com, examining 1,268 dry dog food products to understand implicit pricing structures. The researchers chose dry dog food because it represents the largest market segment globally, accounting for over 46% of the dog food market.

Anderson and co-author Lonnie Hobbs Jr. from Kansas State University applied hedonic pricing analysis—a method that isolates the value of individual product attributes—to determine which health claims genuinely justify higher costs versus those that might represent marketing positioning.

“The sensitive digestion attribute, for example, is in 24 percent of the products but it also commands a 3.7 percent premium,” Anderson explained. “When you think about demand, that’s kind of a proxy for that high quantity and price, so to me that sounds a lot like a demand-driven attribute.”

The Health Crisis Driving Demand

The premium pricing for health-focused pet foods reflects genuine concerns about pet wellness. Recent studies paint a concerning picture of pet health in developed countries, providing context for why owners increasingly seek specialized nutrition.

A 2022 survey by the Association for Pet Obesity Prevention found that 59% of U.S. dogs were classified as overweight or obese—a 3% increase from 2018. Meanwhile, a comprehensive UK study of over 22,000 dogs found that nearly 66% had at least one health disorder, including dental, skin, or intestinal issues.

These statistics help explain why digestive health, skin and coat care, and immune support emerged as the three most common health-related features in the pet food market, appearing in 52%, 41%, and 37% of products respectively.

Supply vs. Demand Factors

The research reveals fascinating insights about whether high prices reflect consumer willingness to pay or limited supply of specialized ingredients. Products with broad market presence and premiums likely indicate strong consumer demand, while rare, expensive products might reflect manufacturing constraints.

Allergy-relief products, for instance, appear in only 2% of products but command the highest premium, suggesting supply-side limitations. “It’s not definitive, but it is likely more of a supply side factor in that case,” Anderson noted, explaining that specialized ingredients like antihistamines increase production costs.

Conversely, dental care products show significant discounts despite potential health benefits, appearing in 9% of products at notably lower prices. This suggests dental features have become commoditized rather than premium differentiators.

Strategic Implications for Companies

The findings offer valuable insights for pet food manufacturers considering product development strategies. The research suggests potential opportunities in combining multiple premium-associated attributes, particularly allergy relief and sensitive digestion formulations.

However, the price discounts associated with certain health claims like dental care suggest these features may be better positioned as complementary attributes rather than primary selling points.

The study also revealed that larger package sizes consistently offer better value per pound, while premium-labeled products command a 15.14% price premium regardless of specific health claims.

What This Means for Pet Owners

For budget-conscious pet parents, the research offers practical guidance on navigating the increasingly complex pet food marketplace. Products with dental care features may offer exceptional value despite their health benefits, while allergy-relief formulations require careful evaluation of whether specialized ingredients justify their premium pricing.

The study also highlights the importance of online shopping tools for comparing products. “Using filters available with online shopping platforms, pet food buyers can make faster comparisons between products by identifying which product attributes they want at the price point desired and read customer reviews,” Hobbs explained.

Anderson emphasized that price differences don’t necessarily reflect product quality: “Pet food buyers should note the higher prices associated with certain attributes may reflect factors beyond product quality, including production costs and marketing strategies.”

The Future of Pet Food Pricing

As the pet food industry continues evolving, understanding these pricing patterns becomes increasingly important for both manufacturers and consumers. The research establishes a foundation for future studies examining consumer willingness to pay for specific attributes and optimal product feature combinations.

The study’s methodology—analyzing publicly available online product information—also demonstrates how big data approaches can illuminate market dynamics in ways traditional surveys might miss.

With pet ownership continuing to rise and owners increasingly viewing pets as family members, the market for specialized pet nutrition seems poised for continued growth. Understanding which health claims truly justify premium pricing versus those that offer good value could help both industry professionals and pet owners navigate this expanding landscape more effectively.